What if your twin commits a crime...

Mystery Squid · 03-21-2006, 04:09 PM

Lawyers focus on past behavior instead of DNA in twin rape case
By Denise Lavoie, AP Legal Affairs Writer | March 21, 2006

BOSTON --A jury began deliberating Tuesday in the third trial of an identical twin who won two earlier mistrials because jurors would not convict him based on DNA evidence that could have come from either him or his brother.

During closing arguments, a prosecutor urged jurors to focus not on the DNA evidence, but instead on Darrin Fernandez's "criminal signature" to distinguish him from his twin.

Two earlier trials for Fernandez, 31, ended with deadlocked juries who failed to convict him because his brother, Damien, has the same genetic profile, and semen found at the rape scene could have come from either brother.

Defense attorney Robert Zanello told jurors that police focused on Darrin as a suspect in the April 2001 rape of a Boston woman after his brother wrote them a letter proclaiming his innocence and offering to cooperate.

He said the DNA evidence -- semen left on the rape victim's pillowcase -- could have come from either twin. "There's no getting around it," Zanello said.

Assistant District Attorney David Deakin urged jurors to look at Darrin Fernandez's "pattern of behavior" in another rape he was convicted of, as well as a series of break-ins and attempted assaults he was not charged in, to find him guilty. But Zanello told jurors Damien Fernandez also has a criminal record, including an assault and battery on a police officer, and has used his brother's driver's license in the past to impersonate him.

"He's got a pattern of behavior, a pattern of behavior that includes a criminal history and a history of deceit," said Zanello.

But Deakin focused on the similarities between the rape Darrin Fernandez was convicted of and the rape he is now on trial for, saying he left a "criminal signature" that "will identify him more surely in this case than his DNA."

In both cases, the assailant broke into homes in Dorchester and attacked the victims while they were asleep. Both victims testified that the man who attacked them engaged in sweet talk or sexual banter beforehand, as if he was a boyfriend and not an attacker.

Fernandez was charged in both rapes after he was arrested in July 2001 while he allegedly tried to break into an apartment in Dorchester. Police matched the DNA in blood found on broken glass at the scene of the break-in to DNA in semen found at the two rape scenes.

Deakin also focused on an attempted assault the same night of the April 27, 2001, rape Fernandez is on trial for now. In that case, the woman, who was also asleep, screamed and scared away her attacker, but not before he engaged in a similar kind of sexual banter he had with the other two victims, Deakin said.

Deakin also tried to distinguish Darrin Fernandez from his twin in other ways, reminding the jury that Damien Fernandez spoke with a lisp, while Darrin Fernandez did not. He noted that the two rape victims and the woman who scared off her attacker said their assailant spoke clearly.

But Zanello downplayed the other crimes and said police only focused on Darrin Fernandez after his brother, Damien, sent them a letter suggesting, as Zanello put it, "Don't look in my direction. Look at my brother."

Zanello also reminded the jury that Damien Fernandez testified that he could not remember where he was the night of the April 2001 rape. He said he was living in Brockton, about 25 miles south of Boston, at the time and seldom visited.

The jury began deliberating at about 2 p.m. Tuesday.

Darrin Fernandez is currently serving a 10- to 15-year prison term in the August 2000 rape.

In his two earlier trials in the April 2001 rape, prosecutors did not seek to introduce evidence of his prior rape conviction, saying they did not want to put that victim through the trauma of testifying again. But this time, they did call the victim to the stand to describe the circumstances of her rape, which prosecutors then used to try to show a pattern by Fernandez.

daniel · 03-22-2006, 11:50 AM

Our "criminal justice" system is so distorted by slavish adherence to procedure, and the process is so dependent on the skill and available preparation time of the attorneys, that a coin-toss would be as accurate for determining actual guilt or innocence. Except that a coin toss would not guarantee (as the present system does) that the rich almost always go free and the poor are almost always jailed.

Evidence is almost irrelevant in today's court trials. So as for your original question in the thread title: it would not make a lot of difference: If you're rich you'll probably go free; if you're poor you'll probably go to jail.

Mystery Squid · 03-22-2006, 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by daniel@Mar 22 2006, 12:50 PM
Our "criminal justice" system is so distorted by slavish adherence to procedure, and the process is so dependent on the skill and available preparation time of the attorneys, that a coin-toss would be as accurate for determining actual guilt or innocence. Except that a coin toss would not guarantee (as the present system does) that the rich almost always go free and the poor are almost always jailed.

Evidence is almost irrelevant in today's court trials. So as for your original question in the thread title: it would not make a lot of difference: If you're rich you'll probably go free; if you're poor you'll probably go to jail.

[snapback]228458[/snapback]

Holy crap! Again I agree with Daniel!

galaxee · 03-22-2006, 01:11 PM

one application where DNA isn't enough.

i love those shows that portray everyone getting caught by DNA evidence, because it "looks cool"

ya. sure.

daniel · 03-22-2006, 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Mystery Squid@Mar 22 2006, 08:55 AM
Holy crap! Again I agree with Daniel!

[snapback]228462[/snapback]

This is getting scary!

SirGreen · 03-22-2006, 07:44 PM

Wow what if they were working together, and
the evil twin is still out?

03-22-2006, 11:50 AM	#2
daniel Cat Lovers Against the Bomb Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Spokane, WA Posts: 11,819 My Car: 2004 Prius Model: Package: #6 Thanks: 79 Thanked 293 Times in 184 Posts Friends: 0	Our "criminal justice" system is so distorted by slavish adherence to procedure, and the process is so dependent on the skill and available preparation time of the attorneys, that a coin-toss would be as accurate for determining actual guilt or innocence. Except that a coin toss would not guarantee (as the present system does) that the rich almost always go free and the poor are almost always jailed. Evidence is almost irrelevant in today's court trials. So as for your original question in the thread title: it would not make a lot of difference: If you're rich you'll probably go free; if you're poor you'll probably go to jail. __________________ Daniel Primary car: Zap Xebra SD, 100% electric. 1.9 cents per mile. Range: 40 miles total, or 32 miles to 80% discharge. Top speed 35 mph. Faster downhill. Uses electrons generated from water power. Gas guzzler for when I have to travel farther than 30 miles: 2004 Prius. "If voting changed anything, they'd make it illegal." -- Emma Goldman "Anyone who has ever looked into the glazed eyes of a soldier dying on the battlefield will think long and hard before starting a war." -- Otto von Bismarck

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Crime Prevention Tip of the Month.	hycamguy07	Fred's House of Pancakes	37	10-24-2007 01:04 AM
Prius Fighter: GM commits to Volt production	Marlin	Prius and Hybrid News	46	05-29-2007 06:53 PM
How bad are we? The CRIME thread...	Mystery Squid	Fred's House of Pancakes	29	03-31-2006 12:17 PM
Being Drunk in a bar now a crime (in Texas)	naterprius	Fred's House of Pancakes	14	03-24-2006 05:50 PM
Suzuki Twin Hybrid	Hornhonker	Other Cars	4	04-28-2005 02:39 AM

03-21-2006, 04:09 PM	#1
Mystery Squid Junior Member Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 3 My Car: Model: Package: Thanks: 0 Thanked 2 Times in 2 Posts Friends: 0	Lawyers focus on past behavior instead of DNA in twin rape case By Denise Lavoie, AP Legal Affairs Writer \| March 21, 2006 BOSTON --A jury began deliberating Tuesday in the third trial of an identical twin who won two earlier mistrials because jurors would not convict him based on DNA evidence that could have come from either him or his brother. During closing arguments, a prosecutor urged jurors to focus not on the DNA evidence, but instead on Darrin Fernandez's "criminal signature" to distinguish him from his twin. Two earlier trials for Fernandez, 31, ended with deadlocked juries who failed to convict him because his brother, Damien, has the same genetic profile, and semen found at the rape scene could have come from either brother. Defense attorney Robert Zanello told jurors that police focused on Darrin as a suspect in the April 2001 rape of a Boston woman after his brother wrote them a letter proclaiming his innocence and offering to cooperate. He said the DNA evidence -- semen left on the rape victim's pillowcase -- could have come from either twin. "There's no getting around it," Zanello said. Assistant District Attorney David Deakin urged jurors to look at Darrin Fernandez's "pattern of behavior" in another rape he was convicted of, as well as a series of break-ins and attempted assaults he was not charged in, to find him guilty. But Zanello told jurors Damien Fernandez also has a criminal record, including an assault and battery on a police officer, and has used his brother's driver's license in the past to impersonate him. "He's got a pattern of behavior, a pattern of behavior that includes a criminal history and a history of deceit," said Zanello. But Deakin focused on the similarities between the rape Darrin Fernandez was convicted of and the rape he is now on trial for, saying he left a "criminal signature" that "will identify him more surely in this case than his DNA." In both cases, the assailant broke into homes in Dorchester and attacked the victims while they were asleep. Both victims testified that the man who attacked them engaged in sweet talk or sexual banter beforehand, as if he was a boyfriend and not an attacker. Fernandez was charged in both rapes after he was arrested in July 2001 while he allegedly tried to break into an apartment in Dorchester. Police matched the DNA in blood found on broken glass at the scene of the break-in to DNA in semen found at the two rape scenes. Deakin also focused on an attempted assault the same night of the April 27, 2001, rape Fernandez is on trial for now. In that case, the woman, who was also asleep, screamed and scared away her attacker, but not before he engaged in a similar kind of sexual banter he had with the other two victims, Deakin said. Deakin also tried to distinguish Darrin Fernandez from his twin in other ways, reminding the jury that Damien Fernandez spoke with a lisp, while Darrin Fernandez did not. He noted that the two rape victims and the woman who scared off her attacker said their assailant spoke clearly. But Zanello downplayed the other crimes and said police only focused on Darrin Fernandez after his brother, Damien, sent them a letter suggesting, as Zanello put it, "Don't look in my direction. Look at my brother." Zanello also reminded the jury that Damien Fernandez testified that he could not remember where he was the night of the April 2001 rape. He said he was living in Brockton, about 25 miles south of Boston, at the time and seldom visited. The jury began deliberating at about 2 p.m. Tuesday. Darrin Fernandez is currently serving a 10- to 15-year prison term in the August 2000 rape. In his two earlier trials in the April 2001 rape, prosecutors did not seek to introduce evidence of his prior rape conviction, saying they did not want to put that victim through the trauma of testifying again. But this time, they did call the victim to the stand to describe the circumstances of her rape, which prosecutors then used to try to show a pattern by Fernandez.

03-22-2006, 01:11 PM	#4
galaxee resident lab rat Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: south of lake Michigan Posts: 9,737 My Car: 2005 Prius Model: N/A Package: #5 Thanks: 0 Thanked 130 Times in 53 Posts Friends: 26	one application where DNA isn't enough. i love those shows that portray everyone getting caught by DNA evidence, because it "looks cool" ya. sure.

03-22-2006, 07:44 PM	#6
SirGreen Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 75 My Car: Model: Package: Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Friends: 0	Wow what if they were working together, and the evil twin is still out?