Tesla Motors sues designer -- Bad Karma?

[Rae Vynn]

Tesla Motors sues designer on competing green car

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Electric car maker Tesla Motors has sued a well-known automotive designer it hired to style the body and interior of its electric-hybrid four-door sedan, after the man announced plans for a competing vehicle.

The lawsuit, filed on Monday afternoon in San Mateo Superior Court in California, accuses designer Henrik Fisker and Bernhard Koehler, the chief operating officer of Fisker's design company Fisker Coachbuild, of fraud, misappropriation of trade secrets, and breach of contract during their year-long effort in 2007 to style the interior and body of the Tesla sedan, called WhiteStar.


The San Francisco law firm that represents Fisker Coachbuild said it does not comment on pending litigation.


Tesla paid Fisker, who has designed for BMW, Aston Martin and other high-end car makers, nearly $800,000 and gave him access to its trade secrets, business plan and proprietary engineering data developed during production of its first vehicle, the Tesla Roadster, the lawsuit said.
Tesla accuses Fisker of purposely providing substandard designs for the Tesla sedan -- resulting in a six-month delay of its release to 2010 -- while using Tesla's data and holding back Fisker's best designs for his own vehicle.


Shortly after completing services for Tesla, Fisker and Koehler announced they were forming Fisker Automotive to put out a four-door hybrid-electric sedan called the Karma.


"What he did is outrageous," attorney Adam Belsky of Gross Belsky & Alonso, who represents Tesla, said on Tuesday. "Clearly now in retrospect, Fisker had a strong motivation not to provide his best work for them."
The lawsuit asks a court to bar Fisker from using Tesla trade secrets and confidential information in his car design, and to award Tesla lost profits and punitive damages of an unspecified amount.
(Reporting by Gina Keating, editing by Gerald E. McCormick)

[mingoglia]

Interesting. I actually put some $$ down on a future Fisker Karma a couple months back...

[miscrms]

Very interesting, certainly sounds pretty fishy. Of course we're mostly hearing one side of it but still.....

Rob

[hampdenwireless]

Fisker is put in pretty bad light from everything I read. That is a shame because its distracting Tesla from its primary goal. It is really a dirty way to play for them to design the exterior of Tesla's car then come out with their own. That said....

Both cars are serial hybrids and the basic idea of a serial hybrid is (as far as I know) not owned by anyone. I hope both cars are made! I doubt that the two cars will vary much from GM's Volt design technically.

Fiskers Carma is drop dead gorgeous. $80,000 is a high ticket car but WOW. Fiskers other cars are also great visually. Its a shame both companies cannot work together.