1. Attachments are working again! Check out this thread for more details and to report any other bugs.

# of minutes the A/C will run w/o ICE

Discussion in 'Gen 2 Prius Main Forum' started by Air, Mar 15, 2008.

  1. jayman

    jayman Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2004
    13,439
    641
    0
    Location:
    Winnipeg Manitoba
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    I'm at my hobby farm and don't have the Prius repair manual pdf's on my laptop, they are on my desktop at home. IIRC they don't draw an awful lot, something like 10 amps

    The contractor I know is actually a "neighbor" around 6km from my hobby farm. I do know he had to spec the bigger alternator when he ordered the supplemental electric heat. He's quite happy with the supplemental heat

    For off-grid applications it would probably be cheaper to use a trucking based cooling system, such as a "reefer" or the truck APU style, than it would to try jury-rigging up a contraption to run off PV
     
  2. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    I should have qualified that statement...I wasn't referring to a house. As far as I can tell, the $80 5500 BTU units that you buy at a big box store (Wal-Mart, Best Buy, Circuit City, Home Depot, etc.) only use 450 to 550 watts. What I mean for a vehicle the size of a truck, they are far lower power consumption than the expensive truck systems or the recreational vehicle roof systems and far less than the boat air systems (not the water/air systems). Almost half the power used. Although I haven't checked the latest and greatest since 2006 so maybe someone has come out with something. I could use the cheap 5k BTU window unit and my options two years ago was to either get two 6 volt golf cart batteries (which I think the big ones are 410 amps) or one big 12volt AGM battery which I think the largest one was 235amps. Now the lead acid battery lose their power rather quickly after a short number of recharge cycles yet the lower amp AGM has a much more steady power loss per cycle.

    The issue is even 235 to 410 amps with enough power to recharge them will fully power that A/C unit through the night and a recharging system for the day, however sunlight against a vehicle basically requires a generator, however I've always wondered how much less generator I could get away with should I use Lithium Ion batteries, solar panels (I think last time I checked I could have 225 watt total in panels on the top...maybe it was 300, I forget). The reason I mention the power tool lithium batteries is I can get these batteries for next to nothing through my family, so I've toyed with the idea of creating some sort of system...and that was back when the NiMah were big....but even then it's likely the better bet is a generator and not worry about the hassle of battery power and just use the battery power for the night.

    It's neat to know the charging of these hybrid batteries are happening at 200 to 300 volts and it's only 6.5amps to charge...I'm sure I don't fully understand how this works, but I know the alternator charging a battery bank is an impossible task...you basically need a generator...I just hate the noise a generator makes even in the engine compartment.
     
  3. priusenvy

    priusenvy Senior Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2004
    1,765
    14
    0
    Location:
    Silicon Valley, CA
    Vehicle:
    2005 Prius
    They're around 8-9 SEER from what I've seen.

    Have you calculated the payback period for going from a 14 SEER model to your 18+? If you pay $0.10 or less per kW I imagine it's over a decade. There are other benefits to having a variable speed air handler and two-speed compressor, esp. if humidity is a problem in summer, but TOC is usually lower with the less efficient models (unless your electricity rates are crazy).
     
  4. priusenvy

    priusenvy Senior Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2004
    1,765
    14
    0
    Location:
    Silicon Valley, CA
    Vehicle:
    2005 Prius
    Yuck. I'd never want to rely on resistance heating except in an emergency. At temps above freezing it's more efficient to use electricity to move heat around with a heat pump than to turn the electricity directly into heat. A heat pump will move up to 4x more energy into a room than it takes to run it, assuming it isn't too cold outside. 12kW of heat could be pumped into a room using only 3kW of energy.
     
  5. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    10 amps ...120 watts...it would be interesting to know more.

    Well, it's not so much the price that I dislike with the truck systems that I have seen, it's more the space they require overall with the whole system in place is far larger than what I have come up with as a solution, seem to use far more power with less power source and are louder. Even RV systems, the most efficient one is a 8300 BTU at 8 amps x 115 amps which would put it at 920 watts...double the wall units at 5500 BTU (which is enough BTU for what I'll need)

    What I have come up with is an Onan generator (which apparently is now bought by Cummins...or maybe they always were...well, I can't find it...it was a small gas powered generator.)

    Apparently the solar panels have increased from 75 watts to 80 watts and now have 123 watts and 246 mobile panels. So that's good news (but only on sunny days)...now known as SunForce...there may be better products. The problem with these type of products is finding the website that has what you are looking for...most places don't cater to mobile applications, so I don't want to take what is offered (which are mediocre in my opinion) by these trucker a/c products yet I do think I have a solution, but I just need to follow through and start buying the products and putting it together.
     
  6. jayman

    jayman Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2004
    13,439
    641
    0
    Location:
    Winnipeg Manitoba
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Is that Real Power, or Inductive Power, and what is the Power Factor? The problem with powering any inductive load through an inverter is that you tend to really heat up and eventually bugger up the inverter. They're fine for resistive loads (Real Power, PF=1.0), not for inductive loads

    A system designed to specifically work with an inductive load, such as the Prius variable speed A/C compressor, works well. A regular inverter that you may hook up to battery(s) will not work so well, with far lower efficiency (Heating)

    An important thing to look into is the output of the inverter. Is it square wave (Far cheaper to build/buy) or sine wave, or stepped sine? Most inductive loads do not like square wave power very much
     
  7. jayman

    jayman Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2004
    13,439
    641
    0
    Location:
    Winnipeg Manitoba
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Manitoba Hydro power rates are among the cheapest in North America, and I wasn't interested in a "payback" per se. I was primarily interested in comfort

    We actually do have summer here, hard to believe after our endless -37 winter. The summers tend to be very muggy. I really dislike conventional A/C as it seems you have to freeze the house to get any sort of dehumidification

    What I like about the Bryant Evolution is that I can set priority to dehumidication. The variable speed furnace fan ramps to the slowest speed to maximize the time the humid air spends across the evaporator coil. The outside compressor will run on the Low speed, which is *very* quiet

    The nice thing is that I can dehumidify on days when the temps are in the low 70's, without freezing inside the house. The e-coil has a factory TXV (Thermal Expansion Valve) to further assist efficiency and performance at slow airflow settings.

    I can program my system to maintain a humidity of say 50%, and it will ramp the fan speed and outdoor compressor to achieve that. Actual interior temp control is "lazy" when the priority is to dehumidification. That's fine, I can't stand a home so cold in summer its like a walk in freezer
     
  8. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    Sine Wave is what I use...no modified sine wave here. I'm not sure I know enough to answer the first paragraph.

    Dometic has a 7100 at 6.6amps for the compressor which is 759 watts, but I assume you have to add the fan amp of 2.5 and you've got a double power hungry system. It's possible on medium that these units may be as or more efficient as a wall unit.

    Air Conditioners, Heat Pumps and Accessories: Duo-Therm Brisk Air 57908 RV Air Conditioner - Polar White - 7100 BTU - Cool Only (Opt. Heat Strip Avail) from MotorHomesandMore.com

    These are the kind of ridiculous systems they are offering truckers.

    Espar - Air Condition
     
  9. jayman

    jayman Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2004
    13,439
    641
    0
    Location:
    Winnipeg Manitoba
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
  10. jayman

    jayman Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2004
    13,439
    641
    0
    Location:
    Winnipeg Manitoba
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Yes, that is correct

    I'm still puzzled about the intended application. Is it for a vehicle, a home off grid, or what?

    I'll be back this evening, and would like more time to think about the application
     
  11. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    Oh, sorry. It's for a gasoline Volkswagen Eurovan Camper so the space is rather small. I used the terms RV, trucker & boat vessels, because those are the vehicles that products are made. The van has been torn apart and customized inside and the only thing I haven't figured out is the air conditioning system technology to put in it. The vehicle looks like a regular VW van with the camper exterior parts removed, so even if I did go with the higher power consumption RV products, I'd have to countersink/flush mount it into the roof so that the vehicle will fit into the 7 foot garage and I also don't want it to look like a camper on the outside, which is another motivation to use the much smaller, much less power consuming 5500 BTU air conditioner units which use about 500 watts on max power. The best idea I could come up with is one of these small A/C units, some flush mounted solar panels on the top of the van, a Micro Onan Lite generator in the engine compartment (battery relocated) and special metal housing welded into the engine compartment with a 235amp AGM (non-enclosed) or a dual 6 volt 410amp (enclosed lead acid). I'd place it in the front of the vehicle for sound reasons and ventilation reasons. It's been a project of mine since 1999, this one is a 2003 and well I've tried various compressor-less systems things from a BayAir ice unit to various fan thermostat controlled units, but the only way to do this is with a power hungry compressor to make it comfortable.

    So my findings is boat vessels for the most part use water and the ones that don't are clearly for shorepower as they use a lot of amps even at low BTU ratings. Truck systems are complicated and targeted specifically to work only with diesel big rigs and recreational vehicles have the top mounted systems which stick up 10 or more inches and are huge when you look at the dimensions...they aren't practical in energy consumption and size. There are some custom individual compressors and fan systems for vans which are primarily European companies, but I can't make sense out of putting together an air conditioning system or at least it seems complicated. So the system I have is rather complicated, i.e. I'm looking at a sinewave inverter, high amp capacity battery(ies), a micro onan lite generator custom placed in the engine compartment, and a charging system for the batteries.

    I've also looked into emergency vehicle units, which aren't any help.

    Carrier came out with a truck solution in late 2006. This is new and likely far better than the previous "best" solution which was the Espar. http://www.trucktrailer.carrier.com/Files/TruckTrailer/Local/US-en/trucktrailer/comfortpro.pdf
     
  12. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    I've never found a sine wave inverter that wasn't ridiculously expensive.

    Dometic has a truck line which are all-in-one units that I could install inside the vehicle and it is at relatively low amps, but still a large size compared to what I'm look at with the small "window" unit.

    Dometic Truck Products

    As far as the location of the window unit, where the best location would be that would minimize noise and be discreet I'm not sure. I'm likely going to put it in the rear roof in a similar custom fashion as the Roadtrek.

    http://www.roadtrek.com/_images/thevan_page/thevan6.jpg

    These type of customized vans are not popular in the states but are widely popular in Europe, so I suppose someone has figured this out.

    I'm assuming these Onan gas generators hook up to the vehicles fuel system. The propane tank on the van has been removed because I removed the LP heater & refrigerator, so I could get the even LP Onan Lite generator, but I hate finding propane stations. I'm told the Webasto replaces the existing piece in the VW tank where the gas lines come in and adds the access for those heater lines. Cummins Onan RV Gasoline Generator Comparison

    The LP heater will be replaced by either a Webasto Airtop 2000 Air Top 2000

    Option 2: Espar Gas Heater
    Most likely the best and most expensive option which work well in any vehicle.One word of warning. The late model EV's have a gas tank that is pressurized to around 1psi. Make sure that doesn't cause a problem with the pulse pump that the Espar heater uses (you'll need to drill a hole in your gas tank). BTW: VW did offer a gas heater in the EV for Europe. You might want to go that route (get the actual VW parts).
    Espar AIR HEATERS

    Other Options: This is likely similar to the 10amp @ 12 volt heater that you are talking about... http://www.bramclassauto.com/SouthWind.php

    Ambulances and Trucks
    Danhard Inc.-Automotive air conditioning manufacturer since 1963.Specialty vehicle,115 volt and aftermarket systems

    They have what seems to be new, a A/C called BlueCool Truck
    http://www.webasto-us.com/am/en/am_trucks_aircon.html

    They have a variety of products for A/C & heat.
    http://www.webasto-us.com/am/en/am_vans_aircon_990.html

    I'll have to locate where I put the list of links of various vehicle air conditioning systems which are primarily based in Europe. These are the U.S. links that I found that may be a solution. The solution seems rather complex.

    You can buy all the stuff do build your custom A/C system from Danhard Inc.(http://www.danhard.com)...And since I will likely need 120Vac power to run the air-conditioner and to run the fridge/freezer, I could just add a heat-strip and you can have a combo heating/cooling unit, but a gas heat system seems like it'd be less hassle.

    Actually, I have seen a VW piece (part of either the Webasto or Espar kit) that replaces the existing piece in the VW tank where the gas lines come in and adds the access for those heater lines. So it should be totally plug and play.

    The Espar is a great heater. Many of these have been installed and they worked in Ford Explorers that went to Siberia. The mechanical capability to install it I think I lack, but it seems like a product I just can't go wrong. The late model EV's have a gas tank that is pressurized to around 1psi, so there is complication that I have to make sure that doesn't cause a problem with the pulse pump that the Espar heater uses (basically I'm told that I'll need to drill a hole in the gas tank).

    BTW: VW did offer a gas heater in the EV for Europe. If I could get the actual VW part then I would do that route, but I don't speak German and finding information in a country that speak so many languages has been challenging.

    The Webasto, called Airtop 2000, available through Reimo, which is an extensive catalog for class b applications.

    Reimo - Alles für Reisemobile, Camping & Caravans. Online-Shop mit Camping-Artikeln, Zubehör und Wohnmobil-Ausstattung. Dächer, Möbel, Sitzbänke, Komplettfahrzeuge.
     
  13. jayman

    jayman Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 21, 2004
    13,439
    641
    0
    Location:
    Winnipeg Manitoba
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Oh, that explains everything. Your options are severely limited, as you have discovered. I'm afraid there is no magic solution that can provide space cooling without a) costing a lot; or b) using a lot of power

    The BlueCool you mentioned is actually a chiller, and it works very well. It can be thought of as a "hybrid" cooling system. It uses a graphite solution in a superinsulated cabinet.

    While the truck is in operation, a regular A/C compressor is used to supercool the solution in the cabinet. Once the truck is stopped, a small transfer pump - like the Prius electric cooling pump - circulates a heat transfer solution through a heat exchanger in the insulated cabinet.

    There is a coil in the cab, not really an evaporator coil as conventional. A fan blows across this coil full of cold liquid, the same way chilled water provides cooling in office buildings. The end effect is a reliable 12-24 hours of cooling without the engine or an APU running

    I like this idea. It should be obvious that there are applications in the residential HVAC market. Geothermal systems can be made very efficient if properly installed. This system can run a compressor during the night when power is lower cost - in markets that tier that way.

    During the hot daytime, the superinsulated storage system can then work as a chiller and provide cooling to the house. Good potential for significant energy savings here
     
  14. abq sfr

    abq sfr New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 28, 2007
    690
    3
    0
    Location:
    Albuquerque, NM
    Vehicle:
    2007 Prius
    WOW, this thread took off faster than a Prius with a green battery! The definitive answer is that it takes less time than going through a Wendy's drive through (usually 15 minutes here). I'd say when the temp is 95, the sun is shining bright, the AC is set for around 75, and you have 5 bars, you *might* have 6 minutes. In the summer every time we go to a fast-food drive through with AC on I'm on 100% ice when I leave. The worst was taking over an hour to get out of a parking garage after a Celtic Woman concert. I couldn't go 2 feet without the ice firing up. Whatta nightmare!:eek:
     
  15. qbee42

    qbee42 My other car is a boat

    Joined:
    Mar 2, 2006
    18,058
    3,074
    7
    Location:
    Northern Michigan
    Vehicle:
    2006 Prius
    This was my original point: The reason you can't find an air conditioning unit that meets your needs is not because of the lack of efficiency, but simply a matter of physics. It takes more energy for your required cooling than you are ever going to get with a battery, unless the battery is ridiculously large and expensive. You either need more power, such as that from a gasoline engine or shore power, or you need a storage system like a freezer plate, that lets you do the cooling when you do have power, and save it for later. Even the freezer plate systems require you to run your engine every day, so that gets to be a bother.

    Tom
     
  16. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    Quite possibly foolish, however I've been looking for an A/C unit that uses less than 500 watts even if it's only 2 or 3k BTU or even if it requires some custom work. I don't mind ridiculously expensive if the cost outweighs the alternative, and I agree the only sure way to make this work is going to be not only expensive but rely on a form of 110 volt (whether in the form of a generator or shorepower...landline isn't an option though), however I do believe I will be able to supplement the use of the generator when outside conditions are not demanding much in the form of cooling such as at night. I'd like to avoid the use of a generator as much as possible at night. There is no doubt that during daylight hours the generator would need to be the primary if not the sole source of electricity even for a 500 watt A/C unit.

    I'm not sure what a freezer plate system means. Are you referring to the $80 window units with the "radiator" being the freezer plate. I'm not that familiar with the technical components.

    I did buy one of these things several years ago when West Marine and other marine stores were selling them for nearly $1500. They stopped selling them because basically they work well only at night and are a pain because you have to put ice in a cooler. Daylight hours and the ice melts almost instantly, however at night it cooled the van quite well for 8 to 10 hours and it only used about 30 watts of power to do it. It's also quite small (granted the ice cooler took up some space). It really put out cold air, but the moment sunlight hit the vehicle the amount of heat it sucked out of the ice cubes was faster than pouring scolding hot water over ice...it melts that fast, so it was a night time solution and only if you wanted the hassle of buying 40 pounds of ice every night which you quickly learn that most places are frequently out of ice during Spring/Summer and at about $10 to $15 a night, this solution wasn't much of a solution which is why the marine stores stopped selling them. Now it worked great at night, I couldn't have been happier with the night solution, yet getting the ice was horrible. I could see this as an occasional solution for a boater or someone who has easy access to a large ice machine, but for the majority of people and especially those wanting a more full-time use application, it just was a band-aid solution.

    Innova Tech, Inc. - Bay Air AC | 12V Cooling for Small Cruisers

    I eventually gave it away as getting ice every night and running the engine during the day isn't a real solution.

    Yes, the solutions are very expensive. I don't mind spending the money when I find whatever is going to be the best solution...however keep in mind a lot of the expense is for items that I need for other features in the "camper" so a sine wave inverter, generator, solar panels, batteries will serve other purposes as well.
     
  17. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    That Celtic Woman concert is kinda like my A/C experience...I don't want my ICE running either. :) It's just not a perfect world, now is it?

    The one big question I haven't yet solved is the best way to charge the battery bank. I'll likely start out with a small battery bank of 235 amps @ 12 volts using a AGM gel sealed battery rather than the much higher 410 amp @ 6 volts X 2 golf cart lead acid batteries. The current charging system that came with it from Winnebago is designed for the stock 120 amp hour lead acid battery. Now if this were a perfect world, I have a super fast recharging system that the Prius and all these hybrid vehicles have instead I am top heavy with high amps yet low volts so charging solutions are slow in comparison.
     
  18. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    Right now I'm in the process of insulating the interior walls. The vehicles interior has been completely stripped out. The biggest problem with vehicles and cooling during the hotter months is the rate of heat transfer into the vehicle. It's like an attic that gets far hotter than the outside temp, so there are a number of things you can do to ensure your attic is cool using passive cooling techniques, namely ventilation and insulation, yet with a vehicle you don't have attic to serve as a radiant barrier/air gap to block radiation from the sun. The vehicle IS the attic. I've read a number of posts about people insulating their Prius especially the issue with the back window (I suspect the redesign prius may get rid of such an all glass design?)

    Ventilation only works well if the outside temperature is desirable enough to use. During hot summer months, this results in circulation of hot air so ventilation is turned off and you can only rely on insulation (unless you came up with a fancy way to have a air gap between the metal wall of the vehicle and the insulation combined with a ventilation system to remove the thermal heat transfer between the metal body and insulation. I've thought of that and it makes my head spin.

    Solar cells...and I'd like to of course make it as efficient as possible and it'd be more of a supplemental power source rather than a primary source for electricity. So it's somewhat of a moot topic at this point especially due to the fact that they don't work when skies are cloudy/evening, etc. The roof is fiberglass and the goal is to put solar panels on the roof, but the metal on a vehicle absorbs the thermal heat from the sun quite well. I'm not sure what is the best form of reducing the heat transfer of the sun.

    I mention the sun, because it's basically the biggest obstacle. Keeping the heat from getting inside the vehicle in the first place and possibly using extremely hot/sunny days to my advantage with a solar panels on the flat fiberglass roof top.
     
  19. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    Speaking of gas mileage...Personally, I wish the van was a diesel five speed...i think there's a six speed in europe, but VW didn't provide this option to the U.S. You can still buy the Eurovan in Mexico, the newer T5 version which according to the VW mexico website it gets 13.48 km/l which multiply that by 2.35214583 and this van has a Mexico mpg rating of 31.71mpg. They don't have city/hwy ratings there. I'm not sure what it gets in Europe, but that's far better than what I get. Now with the change in the EPA from 2007 to 2008 in mileage, and I'm sure Mexico has a strange way of calculating mileage, I wonder how much better gas mileage this van actually gets than my gasoline VR6 engine (which I get 17 city/19 hwy). From some UK forums it seems 30mpg is what people are getting and some modifications getting 35mpg and of course some claiming higher...that's probably the best mpg in a van and especially a relatively large and heavy van. The 2009 VW van for the U.S. will be on a Dodge Caravan chassis...sad but true. Pretty much every place has diesel options except the U.S. You can buy a diesel eurovan named "California", which is odd because it's available everywhere except the U.S. Volkswagen California
     
  20. Air

    Air New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2008
    19
    0
    0
    Vehicle:
    Other Non-Hybrid
    Anyway, back to the topic. There are coolers such as these that claim to lower the temperature down 20 to 30 degrees (yet only to be used with humidity below 75% which says a lot.)

    TurboKool Advanced RV Evaporative Air Coolers