which should I get rid of?

Other factors -

• 
  Personally, I would be concerned about the lessor safety features in the GMC. And, since it is a gas hog and you don't like the way it drives, it doesn't seem like the better choice. Of course, I have no idea what the repair costs are on an A4.

 

Do you need 4WD. Bad weather. Driving off road. Towing. Hauling stuff. If the answer is yes then keep the GMC. I kept my Ford Explorer for the all of these. Western Washington uses the God method of snow removal. God put it there and God will take it away. In the mean time I have to get to work day or night. I also camp and fish and go on logging roads. So the Beast stays for those uses.

 

That's a hard decision when financial situations step in. I would just sell both and get two prius. :mrgreen:

I wouldn't be too concerned with mileage. I had an 87 lincoln that was running strong after 237,000+ miles. Your two cars will have lives as long as these if not longer. I would imagine the audi lasting longer because less stress put on the engine while cruising. SUV's have to work a little harder.

As for price of repair. I have a 318I bmw.. can't get rid of the damned thing.. and i don't want to touch it because every little part cost too much. So, i see where you are coming from when it breaks down to repair cost.

It all comes down to this. Do you NEED the suv? some people use them when they get them for SUV needs.. but later on they become useless. We have an expedition.. we use it for snow boarding and so on.. but all day long, i drive my prius. How about the performance? do you need the Audi performance or will the prius do? the prius does handle fairly well for a mid size hybrid.

You did complain about the GMC though.. which makes me think you use it less.. and have even less need to use it when you do. My guess is you put things in the GMC because you don't want to stick them in your Audi.

I would still sell both and get two Prius :mrgreen: hehe.. sell the GMC

 

It sounds like you have answered your own question. I had a friend (not buying a Prius) who had to choose between selling an Accord and a pickup. He wanted to keep the pickup to haul things. I pointed out to him that he hauled things about twice a year, so it would be better to sell the pickup and rent one at U-Haul for $20/day next time he had haulage.

-gehri