1. Attachments are working again! Check out this thread for more details and to report any other bugs.

Currently Available Prius PHEV Mods?

Discussion in 'Prius PHEV Plug-In Modifications' started by pyromaster114, Jul 10, 2019.

  1. Rmay635703

    Rmay635703 Senior Member

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2016
    2,577
    1,599
    0
    Location:
    Somewhere in Wisconsin
    Vehicle:
    2013 Chevy Volt
    Model:
    N/A
    Sadly in many areas a hybrid pays the same extra fee as a PHEV negating any payback on the system.
     
  2. hydrowindandsolar

    hydrowindandsolar Junior Member

    Joined:
    Sep 9, 2019
    5
    2
    0
    Location:
    Missouri
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Model:
    ----USA----
    Hey all,
    So I just bought my first Prius (2004 model) in August, and I've been doing some thinking and research on this topic. I right away purchased a Prolong Charger (haven't bought the discharger yet), and when I was installing it I went ahead and took the cover off of the traction/NiMH battery pack and studied it a while. As someone mentioned previously, there are 14 wire connections in there besides the 2 primaries.

    One thought that I've been considering is simply taking a second NiMH pack and essentially using jumpers to connect all 16 wires to the same position in the second pack. This way you shouldn't have to modify anything else, because you'd have the same chemistry and everything, you'd just be doubling the amp/hour capacity. Additionally, I believe you should be able to use a Prolong Charger to bulk charge the pack, but you'd want to stop short of the balancing charge for regular use. I suppose you could even use a 120volt relay along with some sort of voltage sensing circuit to turn off the Prolong Charger when it reached the desired voltage.
    The drawback to this is that you're still using the relatively expensive NiMH batteries.

    I'd be interested in this as well.
     
  3. richmke

    richmke Member

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2018
    73
    48
    0
    Location:
    Milwaukee, WI
    Vehicle:
    2007 Prius
    Model:
    Base
    If it were just a matter of delivering power, you would only need 2 wires. Given that they have 16 wires, those additional 14 wires do something. One thing I can think of is that the ECU monitors each bank individually. You can't have two Bank 1's, Bank 2's, etc. The ECU will get confused really quickly with 2 Bank 1's sending different signals.
     
  4. hydrowindandsolar

    hydrowindandsolar Junior Member

    Joined:
    Sep 9, 2019
    5
    2
    0
    Location:
    Missouri
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Model:
    ----USA----
    Yeah, those additional wires just monitor the voltage every 12 cells (2 modules) throughout the pack.
    In the picture below; where the green circles are there are jumpers connecting the modules in series, and where the blue circles are there are jumpers, as well as one of the additional wires connected to the jumper(wish I had gotten a pic of the connections). Another thing this pic reminds me of is the temp sensor (green wire laying on top of the pack). If the second pack has its own cooling system, I don't think you should have to worry about that. [note also that the white thing around the orange wire, to the left of the blue circles, is the current flow sensor] Prius Battery (connections).jpg

    So, the below sketch/diagram shows how they're hooked up, and if you add the second battery as shown it should all act as 1 battery. Prius Battery Sketch.png
     
  5. bisco

    bisco cookie crumbler

    Joined:
    May 11, 2005
    107,688
    48,943
    0
    Location:
    boston
    Vehicle:
    2012 Prius Plug-in
    Model:
    Plug-in Base
    sounds good, please let us know how you make out!

    maybe pick up a salvage gen 2 or 3 pack? even 4 might work
     
  6. pyromaster114

    pyromaster114 New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 10, 2019
    4
    10
    0
    Location:
    USA
    Vehicle:
    2005 Prius
    Model:
    N/A
    To all still following this, my apologies that I kind of dropped off the face of the earth here... but...
    I've been doing some more research as to the Prius' (Gen 2) charge control system, and when it does what, etc.; as well as figuring out what direction (man in the middle, etc.?) I want to go with getting the car's system to tolerate the replacement / addon pack.

    Corrections from my first post:
    I have realized that some of my math was just bad / wrong, or perhaps I messed up something in my massive excel spreadsheet of data... but LiFePO4 would be a problem (for emulating a stack of 12 NiMH cells for each 'block' in the Gen 2 Prius), because the blocks are regularly allowed to hit ~14 volts. LiFePO4 cells (at least all the ones I've seen from manufacturers these days) actually bottom out at 2.5 volts; not the 2.3 volts I was originally thinking. Not sure how I had messed this up. My apologies for this oversight. However, hopefully the below info will be more useful (and correct!).

    Going Forward:
    I have decided that the most cost effective way of doing this (and simplest, technically speaking) is to try and trick the Prius' existing BMS to think there's a NiMH pack, by creating replacement 'blocks' out of Lithium cells. This brings me to the main issue of course though: What cells and in what groupings will effectively emulate a 12S (12 in series) NiMH pack?

    I've been operating one of our Gen 2 Prius vehicles up and down our rural road while monitoring the voltages of the cell blocks via an OBD-II VCI + Phone application. This has yielded some new information that I wasn't too happy about, especially combined with the incredible math / info error in my first post:
    The Prius will regularly 'allow' battery blocks to 'spike' to just over 20 volts (so 1.66667 volts per NiMH cell!) before decreasing regen braking force. I'm not sure what's going on here, and this may be because my pack is incredibly weak and old, but the fact is, if we're replacing these cells with Li-ion cells, we need to account for this! Thus, the new voltage range I'm assuming that the OEM BMS considers 'acceptable' per battery block is 14 volts - 20.5 volts. Thus, whatever we replace each 'block' with must tolerate that voltage range without damage.
    Now, the car does ignite the ICE when voltages sit at near 14 volts for any length of time under load, as it assumes the State of Charge is low. So I don't assume it will tolerate the voltage per block being at 14 volts for long; so if we can just get the replacement battery block to be pretty 'okay' with this under brief heavy loads, it should be alright with the stock BMS behavior.

    Disqualifications of LiFePO4 Cells:
    Unfortunately, this means we're not going to be using LiFePO4 cells, most likely. Since the recommended operation range is 2.5 volts to 3.65 volts for most of these cells, the range just can't be made to work:
    5S (5 in Series):
    Full Discharge Under Load: 12.5 Volts
    Full Charge: 18.25 Volts
    6S (6 in Series):
    Full Discharge Under Load: 15 Volts
    Full Charge: 21.9 Volts

    Re-examination of Li-ion NMC Cells:
    Upon this realization, I went back and reviewed some specs for NMC cells (which I use for my off-grid solar power system for my house). Discharge cutoff for these under load is 2.5 volts per cell. The recommended at-rest discharge level is ~3 volts per cell. The maximum charge is 4.2 volts per cell. This is a massive range, and if my observations, specs, and math are correct:
    5S (5 in Series):
    Full Discharge Under Load: 12.5 Volts
    Full Charge: 21 Volts
    6S (6 in Series):
    Full Discharge Under Load: 15 Volts
    Full Charge: 25.2 Volts

    From this, we should be able to safely replace each of the Prius' 'blocks' with 5 Li-ion NMC cells. These are readily available from various wrecked HV / EV batteries, for reasonable pricing, at about $150 - $200 / KWh, so a few hundred dollars in batteries, and a few bucks for a replacement wiring harness so I can take it apart and build it onto the replacement pack. For the 14 'blocks' in the Gen 2 Prius pack, we'll need a total of 70 NMC Li-ion cells in series.

    18650 Packs:
    I would discourage
    using recovered 18650 cells, as they're not usually designed for this sort of duty cycle. You'd need to parallel A LOT of them to handle the brief current bursts that the Prius can pull / push in and out of the battery pack, and even with proper fusing and protection, the risk of failure (in a violent, on-fire way!) is pretty high I feel. For this, I'd caution anyone from using these lest they burn down their Prius. :( That said, hey, I'm not going to stop you from trying! Just be sure you can yank that pack out real fast if it goes up!

    Further information needed:
    A few things need to be confirmed / found out before we try an NMC substitute pack:

    1) Confirm OEM BMS' 'tolerance' for min/max voltages for each 'block' of the battery.
    Currently we are assuming:
    Min. Loaded Voltage: ~14 Volts
    Min. Resting Voltage: ~15 Volts
    Max. Charging Voltage before Regen Cut-out: ~20.5 Volts

    2) Is internal resistance a factor?:
    For those less well-versed in batteries, the internal resistance of a cell is directly relevant to how much current the cell can supply. Li-ion batteries have an INSANELY low internal resistance compared to NiMH cells. This is one of their many features that make them way better for this sort of application normally. The things I do not know:
    a) Will the stock BMS will tolerate this (it could measure the internal resistance theoretically, though I don't know if it does).
    b) Will this lack of internal resistance will cause any sort of unsafe overloading of the inverter when operating the car.
    My assumption on the latter is a resounding 'no' given the previous PHEV mods I have seen and read about. The first part of this though... I'm not so sure.
    I hope someone can answer this for me more definitively. (I'd hate to drop ~$400 on this project and then have it just not work, or worse blow up my inverter and/or electric motor!)

    3) Confirm that unusual lack of fluctuation of the voltage will not trigger a BMS P3000 (or related) code.
    The BMS has some sort of weird logic conditions for determining when a block is 'bad' or 'going bad', and thus sends error codes down the CAN bus. From my observations, unusual variation in voltage triggers this, not lack of variation. (It prefers lack of variation of voltage in the battery blocks, that is, as this indicates good battery health.) Because we'd be replacing the NiMH cells with NMC Li-ion cells which will NOT likely experience the same voltage drop / spike under load+charge, the BMS could theoretically freak out. Though I don't see this as likely from what I've read and observed so far, I'd like some more data points from others if possible.

    4) Optional: How do we override the state of charge indicator to allow us to expand the battery capacity in the future, to allow the Prius to have a substantial all-electric range?
    The problem with simply up-scaling the battery replacement is this: The Prius will likely not use it as I understand, as it already 'knows' how big the battery is supposed to be.
    I know another user had commented about a 'man in the middle' system here, but reading through the previous posts in this thread, it looked like that wasn't currently an available thing that's being manufactured. Could we maybe have a computer write to the CAN bus? I know not nearly as much as I'd like to about CAN bus, so if this is needed and unavailable, I would surely require help developing this so we can implement a future all-electric range as an expansion to this modification.
     
    ithaclies, 2Fats and strawbrad like this.
  7. strawbrad

    strawbrad http://minnesotahybridbatteries.com

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2011
    953
    996
    0
    Location:
    Minnesota
    Vehicle:
    2005 Prius
    Model:
    II
    Wow!
    This is an interesting thread. A mild plug in conversion has long been a want to do project. Over the years I have removed many plug in conversions. It's not an easy project and most of the commercial products have faded away.

    That's the holy grail of conversions. In 2020 there are now many lithium batteries available in junkyards.

    You are not alone in your quest for a lithium battery conversion.

    Here's a discussion of a Gen 0 conversion using 5 LiFePO4 cells to 12 NiMh cells.
    Antiscab's NWH10 Prius plugin Lithium conversion - AEVA Forums

    The Honda guys at Insightcentral.net are working on LTO conversions.
    LTO "Lithium" battery conversion thread | Honda Insight Forum
     
  8. Galane

    Galane Junior Member

    Joined:
    May 30, 2020
    77
    23
    0
    Location:
    Idaho
    Vehicle:
    2009 Prius
    Model:
    N/A
    Does being able to plug it in really help that much? All it gets you is a fully charged battery when you start a drive. If you never stop anywhere there's a place to top it off before you go back home, I don't see much point except for people who love to squeeze out every last MPG they can.

    I was interested in a plug in mod, until driving the Prius for a while and experiencing how it operates. If the battery had a lot more capacity and it ran more often in electric mode in city driving it'd be worth it to be able to start the day every day with a full battery.

    This town is on an overall bit of a slope so there are routes from the higher side to the lower side it's possible to drive without using a drop of gas. Of course it takes some gas to get up to the high side. No free lunch.
     
  9. bisco

    bisco cookie crumbler

    Joined:
    May 11, 2005
    107,688
    48,943
    0
    Location:
    boston
    Vehicle:
    2012 Prius Plug-in
    Model:
    Plug-in Base
    it depends on your situation. for me, i'm at 97% ev miles
     
  10. strawbrad

    strawbrad http://minnesotahybridbatteries.com

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2011
    953
    996
    0
    Location:
    Minnesota
    Vehicle:
    2005 Prius
    Model:
    II
    As a practical cost saving approach the answer is no. In 2020 it's far easier to buy a OEM plug in.

    As a challenge to do more with less it's a fun DIY project.
     
  11. Travis Sanders

    Travis Sanders Junior Member

    Joined:
    Feb 4, 2019
    63
    25
    0
    Location:
    Hawaii
    Vehicle:
    2005 Prius
    Model:
    Two
    I wouldn't try and marry the two chemistries. Get rid of the nickel completely and replace it with lithium.

    I have a bunch of lithium iron batteries. I might be trying this. If I used six cells per block the cell voltage would stay between
    2.4 to 3.57. the problem is 3 volts is pretty much dead although they can handle 2.4 without damage. 3.35 resting is full . These cells are quite happily able to deliver a high amount of amperage at 3.25 volts. So I would have 84 cells. Each at 3.25 would be 273v plenty high enough to keep the Prius thinking the battery is full. I think the Prius likes to stay around 230 when cruising. So it'll probably try and keep my battery cells at 2.738 volts which represents a very near dead lithium iron cell. at that level of charge whenever I slammed on the gas pedal it could be damaging the lithium.

    Well now I'm really disappointed because I've got a crap ton of these and two Priuses with bad batteries. So my idea would work to turn it into a plug-in hybrid that only went 35 miles an hour and had a really crappy range because I promise you I am not going to put the 1000lbs of batteries in the back of my Prius that it would require to get any reasonable range. I would only be trying to keep it a hybrid with a small enough battery that I wouldn't bother trying to plug in.

    In order to do this right a five cell per block would have to be used with a different lithium chemistry. Remember that you can't just assemble any regular lithium pack and expect it to put out the 100 plus amps without being damaged. A battery that's physically small enough to take the place of the nickel would need to be of the lto or Lithium polymer chemistries. And the lto's voltage is quite different and lower so I think the Lithium polymer would be right and in fact there's already somebody doing it so there's no need for me to try and figure it out. You can find out more about the commercially available product by clicking this link.
    Toyota hybrid battery upgrade pack– NexPower Energy
     
    #31 Travis Sanders, Mar 31, 2021
    Last edited: Mar 31, 2021
    donbright likes this.
  12. T1 Terry

    T1 Terry Active Member

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2015
    585
    297
    0
    Vehicle:
    2006 Prius
    Model:
    Plug-in Advanced
    I am doing this at the moment as a work around after blowing up my traction battery .... long story but you can read some of it here Rainbow Prius Hybrid Powered by Lithium! | Page 23 | PriusChat

    5 x LiFeP04 cells is the right voltage to feed into the voltage sensing wires in the original traction battery. In my case, the original NiMh modules are toast and can't hold a voltage, so the 5 x LFP cells provide the required voltage for the Prius system to consider things are ok.
    If you decided to go with this 2 battery type set up, you will need to run a cable from the LFP negative to the traction battery side of the Prius negative contactor and for safety reasons, cables at the appropriate number of cells to the isolating fuse and and back to the next cell in the LFP series string so the safety feature of the battery isolator switch/fuse is still in the system. It might also be prudent to add a 12v 350 amp Gigavac contactor in the cable from the LFP positive to the Prius positive contactor along with a suitable Mega Fuse and holder so the big battery can be isolated if needed. The Gigavac could be wired to the same wiring as the Prius positive contactor, or to a separate rocker switch so the 12v supply to the Gigavac can be switch off to isolate one battery from the other.

    In my case, I'm using 70 of the 40Ah LFP cells that were part of the Engineer extended range battery that lives in the spare wheel area. Keep in mind, you need a good cell balancing system that can move at least 5 amps between cells if you are going to use LFP or LTO cells as a traction battery, the p*ssy little balancers in the drop in 12v batteries and electric push bike batteries will not do the job, they move 0.5 amps at best, not enough to do the fast balancing required to prevent some cells being over charged on regen.

    A word of warning about this bit from Travis Sanders post :
    A battery that's physically small enough to take the place of the nickel would need to be of the lto or Lithium polymer chemistries. And the lto's voltage is quite different and lower so I think the Lithium polymer would be right

    LTO cells for sure, but I wouldn't tempt fate by using lithium polymer cells, they are the ones that explode in flames if the voltage goes outside their safe operating range. The people who use these cell in model planes etc actually put them in a Kevlar pouch when charging them because of their tenancy to bust into flames. Unlike LFP and LTO cells that do not make oxygen inside the cell when things go wrong, all the other lithium chemistries do and that is how they can explode in flames, the flammable vapours within the cell are already in a rich mix of oxygen, all ready to go bang if a spark ignites them ....
    Check out a video on You Tube, my first Tesla fire, RIP Daisy, a vivid display of just what can happen when you mess with the wrong chemistry cells without a suitable cooling and safety system also connected.

    T1 Terry