Clacking noise left front.

I have a 2007 Base with 144,000 miles. Never had a repair until October 2018 for brakes. I have a clacking noise on acceleration and soft braking. Today the front brakes and rotors were replaced and alignment checked. Two week ago I had the left bearing hub and axle replaced. Still with all this expense the noise is still there. Any suggestions where to look. All this work was done by reputable repair shops.