Please help me decide between 2, Gen 3’s

Hi everyone. Would like opinions between two cars I’m looking at, and on the prices. Both are one owner , Toyota dealer maintenance. First is a 2014, “Two”. 85,000 miles. $9350. It’s listed for 500 more, but the dealer already came down a little. I used my OBD and the check engine light was reset 800 miles ago and a purge vacuum switch valve was replaced (evap system). Drives great. Body is good except a 3 foot scratch on the plastic molding under the passenger side door. Under, the plastic shield is coming off. They are letting me take it to my mechanic to get it up on a lift. Maybe they went over a curb. I have no idea how to repair that plastic piece, if it’s even worth it? I attached a pic for your advice. The second is a 2012, “Two”. 79,000 miles. $9550. That dealer doesn’t seem to willing the negotiate. No issues with the body at all (white). It has the faux leather, in good shape. The check engine light was reset 500 miles ago, but it’s not clear why. It had throttle body service, so maybe that was it. MAF sensor was replaced in 2018. Under the gas pedal is a foot heel hole through the floor mat and the carpet underneath, which bothers me. I’m leaning towards the 2014 because it’s newer and cheaper, if my mechanic can verify the condition underneath. What would you lean towards? Thank you!