Prius? Insight? Fusion?.... Prius? Insight? Fusion?

To the best of my knowledge, these are not yet on the show room floors:

• Ford Fusion
• Honda Big-Insight
• 2010 Prius

There have been a number of test drives by others but I don't think we'll get 'hands on' until sometime later this summer.

Bob Wilson

 

Local Dealer called 30 minutes ago and they were unloading 3 Insights. It surprised the dealer that they showed up today. I guess this is another dig by Honda to get ahead of Toyota.

Base price of the Fusion is going to put it out of reach for many even with the $3400 Federal Tax credit.

Are the 2010 Prius going to start arriving tomorrow???

 

Look at th others, then buy a Prius. Make sure you compare a 2009, vs a 2010. Both are great, but there are some diff's that may sway you one way or the other!!

Whatever you decide, Good Luck on your new toy!!!

 

Prius? expensif
Insight? cheaper
Fusion? more expensif

so whats your budget and buy based on that.

 

Answering these questions should be all that's left in your decision then...

Do you want a hatchback or a sedan?

Do you want an ASSIST or a FULL hybrid?


Insight = compact ASSIST hybrid hatchback
Prius = midsize FULL hybrid hatchback
Fusion = midsize FULL hybrid sedan

.

 

Prius has the best of both Insight and Fusion worlds. Prius has the hatchback functionality like the Insight and the interior room (mid-size) like the Fusion.

The price of the Prius is between the Insight and Fusion too. You should be able to pick the packages in order meet the price you want to pay.

People regret getting an ASSIST hybrid and end up later to upgrade to a FULL hybrid.

 

I am in a similar situation. However, for me it is between the insight and the 2009 or 2010 prius (after having a Chrysler, I'm sticking with Toyota/Honda). My car has had it and I need to replace it soon. However, without knowing when I can realistically purchase a 2010 prius, and at what price, makes a decision difficult. I'd hate to simply go out and buy an Insight this month or in April just because I can, but I may have to buy before we have all of the 2010prius info. Buying a 2009 Prius doesn't seem to make a lot of sense since I suspect that 2009 will be a lot cheaper once the 2010 comes out.

The Prius is larger than the Insight, but not by so much that the size difference is a deal breaker (except the extra 2.5 inches or so of rear hip room could make a big difference). I think the Insight looks much nicer on the outside, and the Prius much nicer inside.
Price and timing maybe key for me.
Any idea when an average guy can actually buy and take a 2010 Prius home from the dealer? Will we have to pay MSRP or higher until fall?

 

It is going to be impossible to tell you which of the three to buy without knowing what you like in a car.

If all you want is low price, but you want a hybrid, then the Insight may be the car -- but don't forget to look at the Honda Civic Hybrid.

If you want a better ride, in terms of space, comfort and features, then look to either the Prius or the Fusion Hybrid. There is a much wider price range when looking at these two cars, so be careful to look for what you want and not buy extras that mean little or nothing to you.

If you want the best mileage, the the Prius is it -- and the 2010, to boot. You just need to be willing to wait and to pay.

I would normally suggest you drive all three in similar conditions before deciding, but I will tell you that waiting one more week will cost you $1,700 if you end up choosing the Fusion but buying it after March 31. Starting April 1 the tax credit applicable to a FFH purchase drops from $3,400 to $1,700. No credits remain available for the Prius, and I don't believe any remain for the Honda cars.

I like the "larger" cars with more gadgets, so as much as I like Honda, I would be looking to choose between the Prius and the Fusion. The Fusion non-hybrid has been well-received, so I expect if you like the look and feel of one now, you'll be pleased with those aspects in a FFH. The 2010 Prius will have many new features, though the HSD is well-developed and dependable.

Perhaps it just comes down to what John1701a suggested: Do you want a hatchback or a trunk? That is very easily answered by me: I wouldn't go without the additional space offered by the hatchback and the fully folding rear seats.

All the best to you!

 

I doubt I'd be looking very hard at many Chrysler products right now, but I am not averse to purchasing a Ford, particularly one built on the popular Fusion body.

Once the 2010 comes out, I doubt there will be much of a selection, if any, of the 2009s. The time is right to buy a 2009 Prius, because what is out there is all that there will be. If you don't mind the color or package, then by all means wait until the bitter end, because prices will not go up. Demand may go up if gas continues to increase, and the supply of 2009s is finite.

I don't know how you'll know the difference size will make to you until you get inside each of these cars. I can tell you the 2010 feels bigger than my 2007 -- and it is! The size isn't much on paper, but it was noticeable when sitting in the 2010.

If so, then I would jump all over an available 2009 Prius. Either that or by a Fusion hybrid (if you can find one) by the end of March and take advantage of the #3,400 tax credit. (Just be certain you qualify.)

You may be able to buy one as early as late May or early June. If gas prices do not rise much and the 2010 Prius is priced high, then you'll have more options. Unfortunately, you've listed "price and timing" as key for you, so the 2010 Prius seems an unlikely choice for you.

 

Thanks for the info, it is appreciated, especially that the 2010 Prius feels a lot larger. I am also under the impression that the 2010 Prius interior feels significantly upgraded.

If I knew that the 2010 pricing would be comparable or only $500 or so more than the 2009 Prius, I would wait it out, and go with the 2010 Prius. If the 2010 pricing is going to be 2,000 more above the 2009 Prius, I'd probably get a 2009 Prius or the Insight.

Too bad Toyota holds back so much information. Some of us could end up with an Insight if we have to replace a non-running care.

 

Be patient! Toyota will come through soon! Very soon!

 

Patience, your right. I hope Toyota surprises with some info soon! I have a 2001 Chrysler that needs more work than it is worth, and as of Friday, all of the windows no longer go up or down (and the amount to repair it isn't worth it) plus a transmission fluid leak, etc. Hence the strong desire to not wait and the possibllity that I won't be able to wait based upon the history of this car. I refuse to put any more money into this thing.

Anyway, I can confirm that 2010 Insights can be had for less than MSRP - I received an internet quote with about $500 off the MSRP for an EX.

I've only owned 2 cars in my life (and I'm about 40): A Toyota Corolla which was a great car that I had forever, and a 2001 Chrysler that I feel like I've paid for twice - once when I bought it and once for repairs - some major - based upon known engine defects, etc! My Chrysler only has 90,000 miles and I'd normally want to get at least 120,000+, but have given up on it.

 

In life, you usually only get two of the following three choices:

• Good
• Fast
• Cheap

IMHO, if the time has come, go for it and don't look back. If you get an Insight, come back and let us know about it. There are several good MPG databases to track your progress. Most of all, don't worry about it. No matter what you buy, a week or so later, a better offer will show up. I think it is something God does to teach us humility. <GRINS>

BTW, the 2009 Prius is a very nice car too. If you have a quote on the Insight, you might visit a local Toyota dealer and see what they can do for you. <GRINS>

Bob Wilson

 

I don't quite understand the hesitancy to compare the 2009 Prius to the 2010 Insight. It has been done already -- take a look at this PriusChat thread on the subject and you'll gain a lot of good information (almost wrote "insight"!).

If you want a less expensive car, the Insight MAY be the one to buy, but given the pressure on dealers now, you should be able to get a 2009 on a great deal. I've seen fully a loaded Package 6 2009 offered for barely above $23,000 -- and that was the asking price!

The reasons to choose the Insight over the Prius do not include gas efficiency, but the Insight should be pretty good on the MPGs. The seats are supposed to be more comfortable or supportive in the Insight, but I've had no problem with the seats in my Prius. The gauges are more conventional in the Insight, so that may be a draw for some.

Aw, heck. I'm just too much of a Prius fan. Honda builds a great car, folks, but the Prius is just better than the alternatives unless you are looking for a total, overall, less-expensive car purchase. And even then, you shouldn't be buying new! By a used Civic! These days, you may even get a great deal on a used Prius.

 

Sometimes events force a decision ... so don't worry about it. Get a good deal and be happy.

Bob Wilson

 

is the fusion not bigger then the prius?