Sold Prius...Lexus CT 200h, Camry hybrid, Prius II?

Thanks for all the replies. So far I have driven Camry hybrid, Ford Fusion hybrid, Hyundai Sonata hybrid, Honda Fit Sport, MINI Cooper, Mazda3 hatch, Scion XB, Scion TC, Lexus CT.

If I had to choose a 4 door hybrid sedan I would choose the Ford Fusion hybrid. It gets 10 more MPG than the Camry hybrid. It drives better and not as muted as the Camry. The interior isn't as nice as the Camry, but the gauges are really nice and have a lot of information. The BLISS system is great and the Sony stereo isn't half bad. I am able to get a fully loaded one with nav, BLISS, leather, etc for $30,800 + TTL. They are not bad priced. I don't like the styling of the Hyundai Sonata hybrid. But, having a conventional 6 speed transmission was a nice touch than a CVT.

I liked the Mazda3 and it is a great car to throw around. They are fun to drive and not too bad on pricing. But, I found that when I adjusted my seat, nobody could sit behind me. I do like to sit reclined and pushed back. I am only 5'9. I am disappointed that even the navi model doesn't come with a rear backup camera. I have been spoiled with one since owning a 2008 Prius. Otherwise, it get's fairly good gas mileage for a 2.5 engine. I am just spoiled after owning a gen II and III Prius for MPG.

The Honda Fit sport is pretty noisy on the highway, but has go cart handling. It makes great use of the interior with the folding seats. I am able to adjust my seat to my position and there is still room behind me to sit comfortably. The front seats aren't the best. The bottom cushion is pretty small. Also, the lumbar in my seat was really high and digging in my back. My complaints are no BlueTooth, XM radio, and back up camera even with the navi model. It is a pretty good bang for the buck. According to forums people have been getting pretty good MPG and some beat the EPA ratings.

MINI Cooper and Golf TDI are solid cars. But, I worry about the maintenance later on.

The Lexus CT is a great mix of both hybrid and conventional car. I know it has the same engine as the Prius, so MPG ratings are good. It is more sportier to drive and has a road feel. My issues are that it is quite expensive and when fully optioned it gets close to $39,000 +.

I currently am taking public transportation to work and would only drive the car during the evening and weekends. I am trying to decide if I should just get something that will get me to where I need to go in relative comfort. That would the financial sound decision.

 

Just an update to what I got. I ended up getting a Honda Fit sport navi auto. I got a great deal on a used 2011 with only 1,400 miles. It is a great car to zip around the city. The engine is smaller than the Prius, it's only a 1.5. Getting on the highway you really have to push it. But, once you get up to speed it doesn't take much to keep it there. I have been getting pretty good MPG. I drove 300 miles so far. Almost all highway around 73 with the A/C running and been getting 36.5. I am more interested in city and I know it is only going to go down. But, I am reading up on how to maximize MPG on the Fit. There are no rattles so far and haven't really read anything on them in the Fit forums. Hopefully it stays that way when the temps drop. The interior is really versatile, but not as big as the Prius. With the front seat pushed all the way back somebody can still sit behind me.

So, on to the things I miss is the smart key. Using a key has been so foreign to me since 2008. It was so nice not having to take a key out to unlock, lock, or start the car. Of course I miss the MPG. If you complain about the Toyota navi, you will hate the Honda navi. It is more utilitarian view, doesn't have the option to avoid toll roads, and it has an OK button you have to press before using it. You are able to use the navigation while still in motion though. That is good since my passenger can use it. There are other things like bluetooth, satellite radio, heated mirrors, and other things. But, I knew that going in. As much as I wanted a Lexus CT, I couldn't see myself paying MSRP for it. I don't drive as much as I use to and having it sit in the street just didn't make sense. I am happy with my decision and will still frequent the board to keep up with the Prius. My parents still have a 2010.