Tire Recommendations for 2014 Prius Two

Sadly just blew one of the four Michelin Defender tires on my 2014 Prius when I parked near the city temporary piping and must have rubbed the metal piece on the coupling.

What do folks recommend for replacement tires that won't break the bank but still will give me performance? I'm in MA so an All Season is needed (I don't have storage for snow tires). More of my driving is local but I do take the car out for a good highway spin...

Michelins and Nokians are $115-$125 per tire.... I do not have a Costco Membership or BJs membership. We have SullivanTire, TownFaire, and such around these parts. A mechanic at a local garage claims a lot of no-name tires could be good choices and are much more reasonably priced. MMMmmmm???? I've always bought name-brands with all prior cars. Car has over 100K on it and the remaining tires have probably another 15-20K on them. I read somewhere that people are also recommending Continental Pure Contact - but I can't find anything listed at tire stores - maybe people meant Pro instead of Pure?

Thank you ever so much for your recommendations. Need to get the Mickey Mouse tire off ASAP!